I'm not a huge fan of McEwan's so I had put off reading this book until my sister read it and enjoyed it. I have a commitment to reading all the Booker Prize winners and this was short so that also made it easier to start it.
I was surprised to find it much easier to read than
Atonement
, where I really bogged down in the initial chapters. It's a darkly comic novel about four men who've all been lovers or married to Molly Lane, who is recently deceased. The book starts out with her funeral, the interactions of the four men during it, and their thoughts on how much they all appreciated Molly.
We then go on to their professional lives. Clive is a composer, Vernon a newspaper editor, George (the husband) is on the board of that same paper, and Garmony is the Foreign Secretary. All of these men and their vocations intersect throughout the story. It was hilarious to hear how the men see and think about themselves. McEwan pokes fun of all these men and their professions, and even of fellow writers.
"He had a number of friends who played the genius card when it suited, failing to show up for this or that in the belief that whatever local upset it caused, it could only increase respect for the compelling nature of their high calling. These types-novelists were by far the worst-managed to convince friends and families that not only their working hours but every nap and stroll, every fit of silence, depression, or drunkenness, bore the exculpatory ticket of high intent. A mask for mediocrity, was Clive's view. He didn't doubt that the calling was high, but bad behavior was not a part of it. Perhaps every century there was an exception or two to be made. Beethoven, yes; Dylan Thomas, most certainly not."
I was enjoying the book for the most part when suddenly I saw what was coming at the end, and thought, "It's not really going to go there, is it?" It did go there. I put off reading the last 50 or so pages because I knew I wouldn't like the ending. Although, the sequences "in the haze of confusion" were quite funny. As was the modern duel.
I don't know. I guess I didn't like how
Atonement
began but appreciated how it ended, and with
Amsterdam
it was just the opposite. I liked the beginning and not the ending, though it did have its humor. I didn't like
On Chesil Beach
at all. Not sure I'll read another McEwan novel, but I was happy to check this one off my list.
I really, really was into the first half or so of
Breaking Dawn,
but did not like the second half at all. I read the first half or so immediately after
Eclipse
and
absolutely couldn't put the book down until the end of the birth scene. I thought it was really intense and I was totally engrossed. Then, afterwards... what a let down. For starters, I actually was a little disappointed that she had to 'cross over.' I understand the reasons why, but it was so much more interesting to me before she did. And the way they told Charlie was totally hokey. I didn't think that part was written well at all. Jacob's new love interest seemed a little bizarre, but it did keep everyone in the same family so I guess I can live with it. And the vampire showdown? It went out with a whimper instead of a bang, didn't it?
Oh, well, now it's over, and I can feel great that once again this 40-ish woman is up on a small portion of pop culture. It's difficult keeping up with the youngsters, but the Twilight series (at least most of it) made it a little more fun to do so. Now I'm just looking forward to the release of the movies!
2008, 754 pp
[Disclosure: This book was not received from the publisher. It's hard to admit, but I actually purchased a copy.]
I read
Eclipse
pretty much straight through in one sitting the day after finishing
New Moon
. These books are addicting, if nothing else. I liked these two books the best of the four, and I couldn't read fast enough. Since so many have already read the book, this post will contain spoilers.
.
.
.
Eclipse
was a fun one, what with the Edward/Jacob rivalry heating up even more. I especially enjoyed the tent scenes. Teenage love and angst at its best. I thought it was a little weird, though, that Bella wanted to be with Edward forever but resisted marrying him. What's the difference when it comes down to it? I also really felt for Jacob in this one. I'm not really 'Team Jacob,' though, but in some ways I'm not 'Team Edward,' either. If you had to pin me down I'd have to say that I was 'Team Bella' in the sense that I'm rooting for her to realize and attain what she really wants for herself. Sometimes that's the hardest thing in life to do -- figuring out what one really wants.
2007, 629 pp.
[Disclosure: This book was not received from the publisher. It's hard to admit, but I actually purchased a copy.]
I have now read through the entire series and will be publishing reviews for the other two books very soon.
Spoilers ahead
.
.
.
I actually liked this one much better than
Twilight
, probably because it was better written. In fact, my favorites of the four were
New Moon
and
Eclipse
. I didn't mind at all that Edward wasn't in
New Moon
very much and was even half rooting for Jacob. It was fun to find out Jacob's story as well. And although some readers felt that Bella's grief was way over the top, I didn't. Teenage love and loss- heck, adult love and loss- is very painful. Sometimes excruciatingly.
I'm excited for the movie to come out. I've seen some of the sneak previews from Comic Con and they look great. I'm also looking forward to seeing Dakota Fanning play Jane.
You know, I haven't gone through chunks of books like this for a long time, and I must say I've missed it.
2006, 608 pp.
[Disclosure: This book was not received from the publisher. It's hard to admit, but I actually purchased a copy.]
This was my first book by Alice Munro, who was recently named as the
2009 Man Booker International Prize winner
. This book of stories is a personal, though fictional, history of her family's emigration from Scotland and their settlement in Canada. It was on the NYT Notable Book list in 2007.
Munro illustrated the struggles of her ancestor immigrants very well. Though I am of German ancestry, I know many of my great-grandparents had many of the same challenges when they settled in Nebraska from Germany. (I would soooo love to read a fictionalized account of their story!)
I enjoyed this book very much, but some may find it a little slow and boring in parts. I'm very interested in family histories of immigration, so I appreciated both the stories and Munro's writing. I have to wonder, though, were all European immigrants a little hard and cold? Perhaps just the act of survival took all their energy.
I am now curious to read more of Munro's work for the Canadian Challenge III. If you have any you strongly recommend, please let me know.
Winner of the 2003 Orange Prize,
Property
by Valerie Martin is an extremely readable story set in the South and is, obviously, about slavery and what it means to be free.
Manon is the wife of a cruel slaveowner and is miserable in her marriage. She idealizes her father, who was kind (relatively speaking) to his slaves, and hates her husband, but really, she is not that kind to her slaves herself. Manon is not a likable character at all, though we do feel a little sympathetic toward her situation. Her attitudes toward slavery were probably typical of the time -- in other words, deplorable.
It is ironic that Manon really is 'property' to her husband as well. I believe that is the thrust of the novel. There is a parallel story between her and her slave Sarah. Both desperately want freedom, but Manon cannot understand why Sarah won't accept her position as slave. There is a certain scene between Manon and Sarah that I *did not* care for, but it illustrated Manon's attitudes perfectly. She was enforcing her 'ownership' of Sarah just as her husband did.
I thought the story was leading up to a certain conclusion in the end, but it didn't happen, and the book ends a bit abruptly. Though I wanted more, the book definitely is thought-provoking. It is a quick read -- I read it in a single day, and I do recommend it if you're interested in the time period or Orange Prize winners.
Valerie Martin is a native of New Orleans so I am also counting this for the Southern Reading Challenge.
"A new commandment I give to you, that you love one another: just as I have loved you, you also are to love one another. By this all people will know that you are my disciples, if you have love for one another." (
John 13:34-35
,
ESV
)
Winner, 1998 Man Booker Prize
I read
Eclipse
pretty much straight through in one sitting the day after finishing
New Moon
. These books are addicting, if nothing else. I liked these two books the best of the four, and I couldn't read fast enough. Since so many have already read the book, this post will contain spoilers.
This was my first book by Alice Munro, who was recently named as the
Winner of the 2003 Orange Prize,
Property
by Valerie Martin is an extremely readable story set in the South and is, obviously, about slavery and what it means to be free.
